Monday, April 2, 2007

Everyone hates the factory

Okay, so everyone has (nearly) unanimously decided that the factory setting is inappropriate. That's okay, I was never really in love with the factory either. It's just that now I can't really use my previz setting for my lighting and rendering II final, which was my plan from the start. Oh well, chalk it up to bad planning.

So, in the factory's stead, I'm trying to decide between an indoor swimming pool or a well in the middle of a forest. Opinions/votes?

Swimming pool problems:
-swimming pools are huge. This may make some shots (which I have been framing with a well) difficult
-The perspective shot with the tiny dragon filling the frame might be harder to sell with the swimming pool. I'd have to use a really wide angle lense really close up, and there will probably be major distortion problems.
-Swimming pool caustics (shudder)
-no well ledge to place the box and ingredients. This seems trivial but it makes the animation so much more complicated. The action of placing a box on the floor requires a much keener sense of weight than merely placing it on a waist-high ledge. Same thing for picking up objects from the floor versus a ledge.
-Honestly, I find a dragon coming out of a swimming pool much more incongruous than a dragon coming out of a well.








Forest and well problems:
-first and foremost, the forest itself! I will have to model and texture trees, which I really really don't want to do.
-the ground: brush and rocks and dirt. More modeling that I don't want to do. On the other hand, it would be nice to have a little forest set that could be reused
-leaves rustling. The leaves on trees are never stationary, and that would all have to be animated. And before anyone mentions it, massive amounts of paint effects up close is a bad idea unless you don't mind your project looking like a video game. Actually, maybe I want my backgrounds to look like video game backgrounds. Who knows.
-the well is still just as anachronistic as it was five weeks ago. So make him a farmboy instead. Uncle Joe came in from the big city and dropped off some cool science magazines and Little Billy decided to order the Dragon kit.
-Light goes out scene. I'm thinking that I'll use a single light on a pole, maybe a telephone pole, that flickers, goes out, and comes back on. The scene will obviously be at night, no moon / new moon, maybe some stars.





4 comments:

Caroline said...

I really like the idea of the forest...It seems a lot more mystical than a swimming pool. It also seems like a more practical place because in children’s books dragons usually seem to live in a haunted forest.

G said...

Jon - I think the well is better than the swimming pool too. It feels more of the dragon world. What's funny is that a dragon of course couldn't fit in a well. But we may not question that if the directios say 'find a well.' It could just be in his backyard if he lives in the country. Perhaps its old and overgrown with roots or something?

maria adams said...

I agree that the forest would be a good setting for the story rather than a pool in a factory....it has that Lord of the Rings feel. Thought about a trilogy?

Nicolette DeLuccia said...

Hey Jon,
I really like the forest also. What if the kid brings a flashlight with him and that's one of the lgihts that go out? If not, I think your idea of a light pole would work. As for the difficulty in modeling a forest, you'll be focusing mostly on your boy and the dragon when it comes into the scene, I would simplify your background as much as possible. You know more than I do about that stuff though! Good luck!